Saturday, October 1, 2011

Where Does the War on Terror Go From Here ?

Unfortunately, due to the fact that the Bush II administration did not pay for the War on Terror with current revenue during their time in office, then answer to this question cannot be divorced from the current fiscal dilemma.

Fortunately, the success of the military and the CIA with the blessing of the Obama administration has had great success in achieving our primary post 9/11 goal of keeping the country as safe as possible.  With yesterday's elimination of Anwar al-Awlaki and two of his key lieutenants the world is a safer place today. This now brings the near total elimination of experienced leadership to Al-Qaeda.  If only we could find Zwahari (sp?  The Egyptian hiding in Pakistan).  I note the use of drones, airpower and covert people in this success.

This does not mean we can let our guard down, but it does mean we need to reexamine what we can and cannot achieve with military might and our intelligence capabilities.  Monitoring bad guys is necessary.  Killing them is necessary since they want to kill us.  Nation building appears not to be necessary and is perhaps beyond our means both in capability and cost.

Now I do not mean we should simply abandon Iraq and Afghanistan in a matter of weeks or months.  We should leave them with as much capability to govern themselves effectively as we can, but we need to recognize what they are truly capable of becoming.  Iraq has a shot at being a Federated state with a national military.  But they will be a violent place while the politics of all this are being worked out.  We are on a path out of there that the Iraqi government approves of and I don't think we can aim for much more.  They are a sovereign state and not likely a source of terror plots upon the U.S..

Our use of drones successfully in Yemen, Pakistan and Afghanistan show that we do not need troops on the ground to fight terrorists.  So what should be our goal in Afghanistan?  It no longer is the War on Terror.  It is to somehow leave them as a functioning nation-state.

However, there is a series of article on Bloomberg that started Thursday that shows even the U.S. in not a nation-state but rather a federation of nations within the United State of America.  The key distinction between nations and states is that the former is a set of common culture and values while the latter has clear borders and the powers of government.

Well Afghanistan has multiple nations within their state and the nations do not get along.  Furthermore, Afghanistan does not have a natural source of revenues for the country except for Opium Poppies.  They do have mining potential but you need some semblance of law & order for that to be achieved.  I am not an expert on how to achieve law & order in Afghanistan but I do believe our military has the best insights in how to achieve what can be achieved.  What they need to be held accountable for what is the best way to achieve this, how much will it cost and reminded that we cannot be there for as many years as we have been in Korea.  Our troops are basically safe when in Korea.  They are not safe patrolling Afghanistan.   Leaving our troops in a position to be attacked through Acts of Terror does not constitute attacks on us in the manner that 9/11, the Underpants bomber or any of the other Al-Qaeda methods did.

We need to declare victory for the War on Terror in Afghanistan and leave in a defined manner.  Our troops safety and our national finances depend on that.

Friday, September 23, 2011

Republican Debate?

it's amazing that they call these things debates.  Debates are when two opposite points of view are argued on the facts and the viewers decide which of the debaters made the more convincing case.

The only thing the Republican candidates disagree on is which of them can pander better to an illogical belief that the budget can be balanced without raising revenues and ending the wars and that somehow we are better off with the Affordable Health Care Act being repealed.  Then people with pre-exisitng conditions can be thrown into the uninsured camp, people who do not have health insurance through their employers can be royally screwed, and the cost of medical care in this country can continue to rise.  Oh, and I forgot, we will turn retiree benefits back to the states.  Mitt actually did a good job of trashing this one, but wait, Tea Party house members don't trust the states to run gun control as they see fit so what do they trust the state's with?

If you live in NY, you know you can't trust the state with much of anything except gun control.

Who does the Tea Party Sound Like?

President Ahmadinejad of Iran.

He denies the Holocaust!  He denies Israel's right to exist in the body that authorized it!  He denies 9/11 was an Al Qaeda event!  and now for good measure, he states that the U.S. started World War II.

This is not an individual who lets facts get in the way of his statements.  It is his way or the highway.

Well, that is exactly what the Tea Party advocates.  Their way or the highway.  They will not compromise on any point.  They will not acknowledge that other views may have validity.  They will not adhere to consistent philosophy.

I am not suggesting that any Tea Party person believes that Ahmadinejad does, only that stylistically they are following the same script.

Of course, most Tea Party people want us to bomb Iran, but the U.S. cannot afford a war of that magnitude with our fiscal situation unless we were forced into it by Iran starting the shooting.

Logistics Require an Exit Strategy from Afghanistan

Those who know me professionally know that my 1st Rule of Emerging Market investing is never put a dollar in a country ending in "stan".  I have that rule because you cannot trust those countries to behave by rules that we recognize.  Unfortunately, the U.S. government cannot follow that rule because when you leave the "stan's" to their own natural outcome you end up with Al Qaeda in Afghanistan.

But Pakistan is the big problem now and we cannot invade Pakistan.  Unfortunately, we cannot keep the troops in Afghanistan without the fuel they need passing through Pakistan. Mike Mullen called out the ISI for things I have believed for some time and he has more access to hard evidence then I do.  We can't give the ISI money to shoot at our troops and we can't keep our troops in Afghanistan if ISI will not allow the fuel to be delivered to them.

It would be nice if Afghanistan military/police were ready to battle the Taliban on their own without U.S. help, but since Pakistan wants Afghanistan to be on their side, maybe the Afghan's could cut a deal with ISI and we could leave sooner rather than later.   Then we could use the money we give Pakistan to pay for drone coverage of anywhere Al Qaeda and its affiliates hide out.  The drone's are a big improvement on the cruise missiles that we missed Osama bin Ladan with in 1998.

And we could bring the troops home, call out ISI for what it is, a sponsor of state terrorism, and save a lot of $ in the effort to balance the budget.

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

The Art of Negotiation

I took a course in Negotiating a long time ago and learned that the first rule of negotiating is defining what you want and figuring out what the other side wants.  But for negotiating to work there has to be some overlap between the desires.  No overlap, no point in negotiating.

This is the essence of what the Constitution was designed to preserve.  A path forward for the nation to move along has to accommodate a variety of views.  The Tea Party instead just wants to lower their taxes to they have more to spend on themselves and then they have the nerve to say the Democrats are promoting Class Warfare.  The Republican assault on government through the failure to preserve budget balance through the last decade by failing to pay for the War on Terror instigated this class warfare.

Now it has become clear that the Republican Party nationwide is abandoning negotiating because they think that by stopping all progress on everything they will win reelection.  Well I can only hope that the voters wake up and vote them out, but it will take the Democrats to make that an issue.

Where does this come from?  Well we see it in Congress every week as they fail to compromise on raising revenues even from limiting tax deductions/subsidies and lowering the overall tax rate.   We see it in NY, as they fail to pass the enabling legislation to create a Health Insurance Exchange even though Republican dominated Utah has one and it works fine as a competition enabling vehicle.  And now, Jerry Brown has found in CA, that the Republicans in the legislature will not agree to anything that allows the voters to express their opinion on how to fix their miserable budget mess.

Republicans are not interested in negotiating, they are only interested in tearing down the safety net.  Democrats need to learn how to run on this point and get the voters to give them a mandate to fix our fiscal problems by addressing entitlements while preserving their important role in providing a safety net that helps those who lose their way in this market economy.

Focus on Middle Schools

NYC's schools are not the easiest to administer, and with the multiplicity of ethnic and language backgrounds, not the easiest to achieve uniform performance.

So, some time ago in an effort to reduce drop out rates, Mayor Bloomberg promoted the establishment of smaller high schools.  My cousin's daughter attended one of these and did fine and the overall program has had success.  So now the Mayor wants to do this with Middle Schools. This is a great idea because if you lose a kid in middle school, it is almost impossible to get them back in high school.  You also need good elementary schools if a kid is to perform well in middle school.  And you need parents who care.  The last one is probably the most important one in forming a good base for a kid's effort.  (Thank you RSL for teaching me that over the last 29 years.)

Last week the Economist focused on what type of school organization produces the best results around the world.  Beyond parental involvement, and teacher preparedness, one key takeaway was availability of schools in proximation to youth. Smaller, multiple schools.  and they pointed out that a such a structure stills supports the employment of teachers, it is just that they have to held accountable for their success or failure.

There is no greater problem in these times than our mass of undereducated young workers, who are only qualified to do construction and we don't have much need for more of that.  So, I applaud Mayor Bloomberg for this focus and want to say that I think school vouchers with family choice of schools is a good idea.  It will take a while for that to have improvement and the states will have to come up with a way of making sure the schools actually are doing there job or else we will have a bunch of Rick Perry's out there who think evolution is a theory and the million year old skeleton of Lucy an oddity that has no relevance to understanding science.

Monday, September 19, 2011

Inconsistency in the Republican Philosophy

The one thing I ask of anyone is consistency in belief, unless the facts change to support a new view.

But when it comes to philosophy, there should be only consistency.  You believe what you believe.

So the Republicans believe in State's Rights for Health Care and any other number of issues, including historically, gun control.

Now, the House Republicans are trying to pass a law that will allow concealed weapons with permits from Florida to be legal in any state, even if concealed weapons are illegal in that state.  Do state's have the right to control their own guns or not?

Gun Control, particularly hand guns, has had me perplexed for a number of years because there is no greater risk to Police Officers than automatic weapons and hand guns.  Yet, the NRA has fought efficient permit processes and any regulation of these weapons that have nothing to do with hunting.  Meanwhile, the Republicans who support law & order and protecting the police, endorse the NRA positions.

It is bad enough that this allows haphazard regulations across states, but at least I know as a resident of NY, that there is some effort to protect me from some random person starting to shoot a concealed handgun when I am in proximity to them.  Now, the House Republicans want to end that comfort for me and allow Florida's laws to override NY's.

Are they for State's Rights or NOT!  and if they are not, where does that put the philosophical back drop  to fight the Affordable Health Care Act