The issues are outlined clearly today by the WSJ and NYT editorials on Medicare, although in my heart I don't quite understand why the 2008 election didn't decide this. I guess in a democracy, no issue is decided until the losers believe that pursuing an issue is a waste of time.
I will give the WSJ 4 stars for laying out the crux of the issue. They said do you want a faceless bureaucracy deciding how to ration healthcare or do you want a private market solution. What they didn't say explicitly, is the latter will result in faceless private insurance companies rationing health care and pricing the products to cover the cost of keeping people out of the system and a 20% ROE. But they did identify the key difference between the political parties.
The NYT to its credit tells the Democrats that they need to educate the voters better on how they plan to control the cost of healthcare and not simply run on this year's version of "Death Panels". I cannot resist saying that what is good for the goose, is good for the gander. The Republicans who used the false Death Panel statements deserve to lose because the Ryan plan would fundamentally change Medicare. Instead of a government bureaucracy that you can with difficulty appeal to, you would have a private sector solution that would be incomprehensible and expert at making appeals difficult.
Finally, for today, the NYT states that the property tax cap should be voted down so voters can see the Legislators make the tough decisions on controlling the costs that property taxes pay for. That might work in most states but how does it work in a state where the legislators routinely fail to pass budgets, maintain ethical standards and gerrymander districts so that no incumbent can lose. Until all legislative districts are based upon logical geometric shapes (and I include Congress here) so that candidates have to work from the middle to their partisan point of view, blunt forces will sometimes be needed to control spending.
Thursday, May 26, 2011
Monday, May 23, 2011
AP Poll: 54% & 59% believe Budget Balance possible without touching Entitlements
No Room in the headline for the details. 54% believe that Medicare does not have to be touched and 59% believe that Social Security does not have to be touched in order to balance the budget.
This means that less then 50% of the population understands that there is a problem with entitlements and something must be done. Social Security's problem is over the longer term and The Fiscal Deficit Commission suggested how to do it. Raise the retirement age from 66 to 70 over 35 years and change the inflation rate from Labor Rate increases to CPI. Both reasonable paths if the partisan divide can be bridged.
As I have written now numerous times, something needs to be done for Medicare and the Affordable Health Insurance Act of 2010 ("Obamacare" to its detractors) starts the process of addressing Medicare. Does more need to be done? Almost certainly, but it will only get done if the partisan divide is bridged.
How can the divide be bridged? The Republicans have to allow revenue rates to be raised in an intelligent fashion to give the Democrats the cover to agree to cutting unaffordable (after the revenue increase) elements. The Democrats have to give the Republicans cover by agreeing to spending cuts that will balance the budget eventually after the revenue increases are realized.
This is what the Deficit Reduction Commission was all about and it is time both parties started working on it together instead of fighting over partisan angles.
Of course, I think the Republicans are not up to this because they know that the 2012 - 2016 cycle is their chance to appoint justices that will bury a woman's right to choice. It is unlikely that the older liberal justices will be on the court in 2016 and if Obama fails to win reelection, it is only a matter of time until Roe v Wade is overturned and buried by the a solid conservative majority on the court. This is the real decisive issue for the 2012 election and the Republicans do not want Obama to be able to claim a victory on balancing the budget prior to the election. Their only hope for beating him is the claim of fiscal irresponsibility even when they are not being honest about how to achieve a responsible budget. Democrats are only marginally better so there is a low probability of reasonable progress on this until after January 2013.
This means that less then 50% of the population understands that there is a problem with entitlements and something must be done. Social Security's problem is over the longer term and The Fiscal Deficit Commission suggested how to do it. Raise the retirement age from 66 to 70 over 35 years and change the inflation rate from Labor Rate increases to CPI. Both reasonable paths if the partisan divide can be bridged.
As I have written now numerous times, something needs to be done for Medicare and the Affordable Health Insurance Act of 2010 ("Obamacare" to its detractors) starts the process of addressing Medicare. Does more need to be done? Almost certainly, but it will only get done if the partisan divide is bridged.
How can the divide be bridged? The Republicans have to allow revenue rates to be raised in an intelligent fashion to give the Democrats the cover to agree to cutting unaffordable (after the revenue increase) elements. The Democrats have to give the Republicans cover by agreeing to spending cuts that will balance the budget eventually after the revenue increases are realized.
This is what the Deficit Reduction Commission was all about and it is time both parties started working on it together instead of fighting over partisan angles.
Of course, I think the Republicans are not up to this because they know that the 2012 - 2016 cycle is their chance to appoint justices that will bury a woman's right to choice. It is unlikely that the older liberal justices will be on the court in 2016 and if Obama fails to win reelection, it is only a matter of time until Roe v Wade is overturned and buried by the a solid conservative majority on the court. This is the real decisive issue for the 2012 election and the Republicans do not want Obama to be able to claim a victory on balancing the budget prior to the election. Their only hope for beating him is the claim of fiscal irresponsibility even when they are not being honest about how to achieve a responsible budget. Democrats are only marginally better so there is a low probability of reasonable progress on this until after January 2013.
Friday, May 20, 2011
Caroline Baum & I Agree:
That is almost as unusual as Mitt, Newt & I agreeing.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-05-19/both-parties-wrong-on-tax-breaks-for-big-oil-commentary-by-caroline-baum.html
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-05-19/both-parties-wrong-on-tax-breaks-for-big-oil-commentary-by-caroline-baum.html
Thursday, May 19, 2011
Oil Tax Shelters and Politics
Well, my friend RedStateVT has pointed out an inconsistency that I must comment on. It turns out both Oil Companies and Mining Companies benefit from tax shelters at the expense of Individual Rate Payers. I was going to castigate Republicans for their lack of support for ending such tax shelters but then it turns out certain Democrats don't want to end the mining breaks.
Wait a minute, isn't curing the deficit a common goal of both parties. Wouldn't it make sense to package Republican and Democratic industries to raise revenue while ending unfair corporate welfare. Of course it would, but then incumbents might be at risk of losing elections. Well, lead and educate the voters.
The fact is that corporate effective tax rates have fallen from 35% to something well less then 20%, while Individuals are somewhere around 31% overall with the 35% top rate. It is time for corporations pay their fair share, especially if the earnings are on shore. That does not have to mean 35% but a well designed tax overhaul (such as that recommended by The Deficit Reduction Commission) could raise revenue while cutting tax rates for all. That would be a good thing. Tackle 30% of the deficit with revenue increases and the other 70% by reducing spending. Yet no politician has really taken up promoting the Deficit Reduction Commission, including its sponsor the President. He should lead and educate the voters, also.
And while we are at it, it makes no sense for Hedge Fund employees to get annual income treated as a capital gain just because it is a "carried interest". If it comes as a salary, it should be treated as ordinary income. If it at risk in an investment and held for more then a year, well then it deserves capital gains treatment.
Wait a minute, isn't curing the deficit a common goal of both parties. Wouldn't it make sense to package Republican and Democratic industries to raise revenue while ending unfair corporate welfare. Of course it would, but then incumbents might be at risk of losing elections. Well, lead and educate the voters.
The fact is that corporate effective tax rates have fallen from 35% to something well less then 20%, while Individuals are somewhere around 31% overall with the 35% top rate. It is time for corporations pay their fair share, especially if the earnings are on shore. That does not have to mean 35% but a well designed tax overhaul (such as that recommended by The Deficit Reduction Commission) could raise revenue while cutting tax rates for all. That would be a good thing. Tackle 30% of the deficit with revenue increases and the other 70% by reducing spending. Yet no politician has really taken up promoting the Deficit Reduction Commission, including its sponsor the President. He should lead and educate the voters, also.
And while we are at it, it makes no sense for Hedge Fund employees to get annual income treated as a capital gain just because it is a "carried interest". If it comes as a salary, it should be treated as ordinary income. If it at risk in an investment and held for more then a year, well then it deserves capital gains treatment.
Tuesday, May 17, 2011
I Agree With Newt & Mitt: Well I Never Thought that Would Happen
O.K., so they don't agree with me that Universal Health Insurance should be the goal, but they do agree that the Ryan Plan is too radical. Thanks to the WSJ today, we now have some facts to support our view that it would lead to dying people in the streets like in the Middle Ages by letting wealth ration healthcare.
Paul Ryan (R. Wisconsin) said on Monday, "Our plan is to give seniors the power to deny business to inefficient providers." i.e. the private sector insurance companies that would be writing the new elderly health care insurance under the Ryan Plan.
Both Newt and Mitt called this too radical. Well, not only do I agree with that, but I think it is impractical and will not work. Many of the elderly do not have the mental ability to understand and differentiate between insurance policies and specific coverages. I have a hard enough time doing this as a non-elderly person because the information is not readily available. Now add in a little feeblemindedness or Alzheimers and no children, and who will make the informed decision for any specific elderly individual. Will they even sign up for a policy or bank (or have someone steal) the money the government sends them. Then the ambulance takes them to the hospital (as an uninsured), gives them treatment (that is passed onto all the insured) and we are back where we were in 2009 with the cost for the insured including the cost for the uninsured except this time it is the elderly as well as everyone else. Or, the uninsured die in the street without treatment.
We have already seen the private sector Health Care Companies protect their profits by denying coverage to those with preexisting conditions. We know they are in business to generate a profit and spend a lot of money to make sure that any claims they pay are valid (and shouldn't be paid by somebody else.) So, they will price the policy to produce a profit and the way they will do that is by denying coverage for things. In other words, ration. Who is likely to be rationed? Those who no longer have the intelligence or wealth to figure things out and get the proper coverage. How is this different from a "Death Panel"? Why is it so bad to have a government panel set national standard for coverage (yes, that will be a form of rationing at some level) and protect the population from the Health Insurance Company's profit protection actions.
Paul Ryan (R. Wisconsin) said on Monday, "Our plan is to give seniors the power to deny business to inefficient providers." i.e. the private sector insurance companies that would be writing the new elderly health care insurance under the Ryan Plan.
Both Newt and Mitt called this too radical. Well, not only do I agree with that, but I think it is impractical and will not work. Many of the elderly do not have the mental ability to understand and differentiate between insurance policies and specific coverages. I have a hard enough time doing this as a non-elderly person because the information is not readily available. Now add in a little feeblemindedness or Alzheimers and no children, and who will make the informed decision for any specific elderly individual. Will they even sign up for a policy or bank (or have someone steal) the money the government sends them. Then the ambulance takes them to the hospital (as an uninsured), gives them treatment (that is passed onto all the insured) and we are back where we were in 2009 with the cost for the insured including the cost for the uninsured except this time it is the elderly as well as everyone else. Or, the uninsured die in the street without treatment.
We have already seen the private sector Health Care Companies protect their profits by denying coverage to those with preexisting conditions. We know they are in business to generate a profit and spend a lot of money to make sure that any claims they pay are valid (and shouldn't be paid by somebody else.) So, they will price the policy to produce a profit and the way they will do that is by denying coverage for things. In other words, ration. Who is likely to be rationed? Those who no longer have the intelligence or wealth to figure things out and get the proper coverage. How is this different from a "Death Panel"? Why is it so bad to have a government panel set national standard for coverage (yes, that will be a form of rationing at some level) and protect the population from the Health Insurance Company's profit protection actions.
Saturday, May 14, 2011
Mitt tried to explain the truth but failed
By now it should have become clear that I believe there are two paths to follow with health care. The Republican Plan to allow wealth and state governments to ration healthcare or the Democrats Plan to have some overall safety net that ignores wealth and will have to ration some stuff though the Oversight Cost Control Panel that the Healthcare Affordability Act provides for.
The former will have poor people suffering in the streets someday while the latter threatens to bankrupt the government's finances if not implemented well.
So here comes Mitt Romney, the designer of the Healthcare Affordability Act for all practical purposes, to explain why it was good for Massachusetts but not for the whole country. He could have said, we don't have as many obese poor people in Mass as there are in the predominantly rural states that vote Republican so Mass can afford it but the U.S. cannot. That would have had an element of truth to it, but he would have insulted all the obese people in Republican states. He could have said, it is a state's right's issue and Medicare and Medicaid should be put under the control of each state. That could have had an element of truth. But how would Florida afford it and the Republican Fat Cats in the rich states don't want all those poor obese people moving from the Republican States to the Democratic States, that would upset the electoral college arithmetic that provides support for not raising taxes.
So here is what I think Mitt was trying to say and didn't want to put the idea squarely out there into the debate because the Republican point of view will lose the 2012 election hands down. It was good for Mass because it got all the uninsured into the insured system and then costs can be controlled. And Mass does have more people with insurance because it is wealthier and has fewer uninsured then the U.S. as a whole. The only way the U.S. can afford it is to raise revenue and ration certain things through Medicare and Medicaid. But rationing is another word for "Death Panels" and the Republicans will not support either revenue increases or Death Panels. So the only path the Republicans are leading us down on health care is either bankruptcy of the system or putting it all in the hands of the private sector insurance companies and letting them ration and make profits and in general provide frustration to the general population. Of course, this path allows the wealthy (and here I mean the really wealthy because if you only have $100,000 to $200,000 to live on in retirement, you won't have enough) to buy extra insurance and access to get around all this. Of course, Mitt understands this but knows the truth won't win the Republican nomination or the 2012 election.
This is not easy for the Democrats to explain either. Medicare for all would provide the highest level of cost control, but that couldn't pass the realty of putting all the Health Insurance Companies out of business. In any case, some rationing will occur eventually in some formal setting as opposed to the way it occurs now based on wealth and access to insurance. But at least they want a middle road. Revenue increases and some basic health care coverage for all. Get the uninsured into the system and figure out a way to reduce emergency room usage for things are not emergencies. Look for other ways to control costs. Malpractice Reform would not hurt either but that is a bill still waiting to be passed.
Sorry for the length again, but this is something I am passionate about. I think in my next career I want to figure out a way to provide affordable (this is a huge issue, $20,000 is affordable for me, but not John Doe who makes $50,000 a year) healthcare for all with minimal rationing, but I don't know enough now to be a real expert. This is a vey complicated subject. However, I do know that obesity and "end of life" desire for low probability "Hail Mary" treatments are probably the biggest hurdle to controlling costs once emergency room access is controlled. Unfortunately, until 2014 we will be making little progress on this and the Republicans would send us back to the starting line in 2013 if they get a chance.
The former will have poor people suffering in the streets someday while the latter threatens to bankrupt the government's finances if not implemented well.
So here comes Mitt Romney, the designer of the Healthcare Affordability Act for all practical purposes, to explain why it was good for Massachusetts but not for the whole country. He could have said, we don't have as many obese poor people in Mass as there are in the predominantly rural states that vote Republican so Mass can afford it but the U.S. cannot. That would have had an element of truth to it, but he would have insulted all the obese people in Republican states. He could have said, it is a state's right's issue and Medicare and Medicaid should be put under the control of each state. That could have had an element of truth. But how would Florida afford it and the Republican Fat Cats in the rich states don't want all those poor obese people moving from the Republican States to the Democratic States, that would upset the electoral college arithmetic that provides support for not raising taxes.
So here is what I think Mitt was trying to say and didn't want to put the idea squarely out there into the debate because the Republican point of view will lose the 2012 election hands down. It was good for Mass because it got all the uninsured into the insured system and then costs can be controlled. And Mass does have more people with insurance because it is wealthier and has fewer uninsured then the U.S. as a whole. The only way the U.S. can afford it is to raise revenue and ration certain things through Medicare and Medicaid. But rationing is another word for "Death Panels" and the Republicans will not support either revenue increases or Death Panels. So the only path the Republicans are leading us down on health care is either bankruptcy of the system or putting it all in the hands of the private sector insurance companies and letting them ration and make profits and in general provide frustration to the general population. Of course, this path allows the wealthy (and here I mean the really wealthy because if you only have $100,000 to $200,000 to live on in retirement, you won't have enough) to buy extra insurance and access to get around all this. Of course, Mitt understands this but knows the truth won't win the Republican nomination or the 2012 election.
This is not easy for the Democrats to explain either. Medicare for all would provide the highest level of cost control, but that couldn't pass the realty of putting all the Health Insurance Companies out of business. In any case, some rationing will occur eventually in some formal setting as opposed to the way it occurs now based on wealth and access to insurance. But at least they want a middle road. Revenue increases and some basic health care coverage for all. Get the uninsured into the system and figure out a way to reduce emergency room usage for things are not emergencies. Look for other ways to control costs. Malpractice Reform would not hurt either but that is a bill still waiting to be passed.
Sorry for the length again, but this is something I am passionate about. I think in my next career I want to figure out a way to provide affordable (this is a huge issue, $20,000 is affordable for me, but not John Doe who makes $50,000 a year) healthcare for all with minimal rationing, but I don't know enough now to be a real expert. This is a vey complicated subject. However, I do know that obesity and "end of life" desire for low probability "Hail Mary" treatments are probably the biggest hurdle to controlling costs once emergency room access is controlled. Unfortunately, until 2014 we will be making little progress on this and the Republicans would send us back to the starting line in 2013 if they get a chance.
Politicians Pander (and do not lead) Again
Both parties used their Saturday Radio Address to address the issue of "high" gasoline prices. (Who listen's to these anyway, I listen to a lot of radio and have never hear one, but thanks to reporters, I always get the gist.)
Anyway, both the President and some Republican bimbo from PA, basically said Drill Baby Drill (not that I ever saw a baby drill, but they do drool) and that will somehow control the price of gasoline. Do they really think that if the U.S. suddenly found 20 bn barrels of oil and sold 1 bn a year that it would have serious effect on the price of gasoline? No!! The BRICS increased usage of gasoline would absorb that in no time at all. The only thing that will control the price of gasoline is less usage of gasoline. Either drive less or get a more fuel efficient car and we can only hope that T. Boon Pickens is right and there is both enough natural gas and an efficient way to have it power a car (both of which have to be proven). So the only person leading on this issue is T. Boon. Everyone else is pretending that drilling helps.
Anyway, there is a lot of natural gas in the shale formations of the U.S., but I wish I could believe my energy experts that it is safe to hydrofragment the shale without polluting the water. Their statements make sense to me when they explain them, but then I see experts who study Pennsylvania hydrofragging and they say it is not clear that the chemicals do not find their way up from 7000 feet down. I don't know what is correct but I wish the experts would figure it out and put it to rest.
Anyway, both the President and some Republican bimbo from PA, basically said Drill Baby Drill (not that I ever saw a baby drill, but they do drool) and that will somehow control the price of gasoline. Do they really think that if the U.S. suddenly found 20 bn barrels of oil and sold 1 bn a year that it would have serious effect on the price of gasoline? No!! The BRICS increased usage of gasoline would absorb that in no time at all. The only thing that will control the price of gasoline is less usage of gasoline. Either drive less or get a more fuel efficient car and we can only hope that T. Boon Pickens is right and there is both enough natural gas and an efficient way to have it power a car (both of which have to be proven). So the only person leading on this issue is T. Boon. Everyone else is pretending that drilling helps.
Anyway, there is a lot of natural gas in the shale formations of the U.S., but I wish I could believe my energy experts that it is safe to hydrofragment the shale without polluting the water. Their statements make sense to me when they explain them, but then I see experts who study Pennsylvania hydrofragging and they say it is not clear that the chemicals do not find their way up from 7000 feet down. I don't know what is correct but I wish the experts would figure it out and put it to rest.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)